Stormy Waters

Climate Change in Morecambe Bay

Geographr: Karl and Ali CC BY-SA 2.0

Climate

Noun

Origin: Late Middle English, possibly originally from greek "klinein", meaning slope

The weather conditions prevailing in an area in general or over a long period...a region with particular prevailing weather conditions

The climate of the bay throughout history

It's likely that the bay area has been ice-free, vegetated, and capable of supporting grazing animals since at least 14,500 years BP. Evidence of human occupation goes back to the Mesolithic- 12,000 years BP. The bay itself has been infilling with sediment since at least the 18th century, partially due to manmade changes such as the construction of the railway viaduct and the reclamation of the saltmarshes.

Iain A Williamson: The Late Devensian Climate around Morecambe Bay
Geographr: Karl and Ali CC BY-SA 2.0

Equilibrium

The bay is an extremely dynamic environment, but periodically reaches a state of equilibrium where the inflow and outflow of sediment are relatively equal, the river channels don't move too much, and there isn't a lot of erosion or flooding. Major disturbances have happened in the 19th century, and the 1950s and 60s. Climate changes or mitigation against them could trigger a period of instability.

North West Estuaries Processes Reports- Halcrow: http://www.channelcoast.org/northwest/latest/index.php?link=&dla=download&id=5&cat=1/Kent_Estuary_Processes_Report_Final.pdf
Wikimedia Commons: Ian Taylor CC BY-SA 2.0

Likely symptoms of climate change

  • Changing weather patterns
  • Changing biodiversity
  • Sea level changes
  • Sea acidification from dissolved Carbon Dioxide
  • Temperature rise in the sea and rivers running into the bay
  • Impact from manmade attempts at mitigation
Heysham Heritage Association http://www.heyshamheritage.org.uk/

Predictions for the North West

  • Increase in mean winter temperatures of 2.6°C
  • Increase in mean summer temperatures of 3.7°C
  • Increase in mean winter precipitation of 16%
  • Increase in mean summer precipitation of 22%
  • Less sea level rise than the south due to the effects of isostatic rebound (North) and subsidence (South)
  • UK-wide increase in severity and incidence of extreme weather events
UK Climate Projections Version 3, 2010: http://ukclimateprojections.metoffice.gov.uk/media.jsp?mediaid=87851&filetype=pdf
Flickr: Gidzy CC BY 2.0

Impacts

Of the habitats in the bay area, the coastal limestones, saltmarsh, coastal cliffs, and saline lagoons are judged most at risk of "significant character change" or being destroyed altogether.

Responding to the impacts of climate change on the Morecambe Bay Limestones NCA https://climateandus.com/download/00061MorecombeBay_NCA_CC_Impacts
Geographr: Karl and Ali CC BY-SA 2.0

Impact on limestones

  • Increases in biomass due to longer growing season
  • Invading species outcompeting existing species, and changes in composition of communities
  • Increased erosion of thin soils in grykes due to more intense rainfall
  • Change in chemistry of rainfall leading to more erosion of limestone
  • Less frost damage due to warmer winters
  • Increased risk of wildfires
  • Decreased flowering and increased vulnerability to pathogens in heather species
Flickr: Stephen Dawson CC BY-SA 2.0

Impact on coastal habitats

  • Increased tidal flooding and higher storm surge heights
  • Acceleration of erosion
  • Increased sedimentation and barrier breaches causing loss of saline lagoons
  • Oxidation of sediments and organic matter triggering release of Carbon Dioxide and Methane
  • Changes in river flows changing the energy and hence sedimentation accretion in the bay
  • Managed realignment and hard coastal defences resulting in coastal squeeze or total habitat loss
Geographr: Karl and Ali CC BY-SA 2.0

Sea Level Changes

  • Sea Level changes come from multiple sources: melting of ice sheets, isostatic adjustment, and storm surges
  • We should also expect decreasing salinity and increased wave height
  • Projected sea level rise for Edinburgh is 7-54cm by 2095, relative to 1995 levels
  • Projection for Morecambe Bay is that sea level rise won't be a major issue until 50-100 years time
  • But ...current defenses, for example the training walls that keep the route to Sunderland Village open, are becoming increasingly ineffective
UKCP09 https://ukclimateprojections.metoffice.gov.uk/
Geographr: David Long CC BY-SA 2.0

Invasive Sea Species

  • MCS report record number of sitings of Barrel jellyfish (Rhizostoma octopus), Mauve stingers (Pelagia noctiluca), and Portuguese Man-of-War (Physalia physalia)
  • Black seabream (Spondyliosoma cantharus), John Dory (Zeus faber) and anchovy (Engraulis encrasicolus) are becoming more common
  • Leathery sea squirts (Styela clava), wireweed (Sargassum muticum), Orange tipped sea squirt (Corella eumyota), Acorn barnacle (Amphibalanus improvises) all present in increasing numbers in the North-West. All outcompete incumbent species
Sustainability Appraisal Report Card- Biodiversity July 2016 https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/535161/SA_Report_cards_Biodiversity.pdf
Andrew Butko via Wikimedia Commons CC BY-SA 3.0

Invasive Land/Freshwater Species

  • In the rivers: Signal Crayfish (Pacifastacus leniusculus)
  • On the limestone- Cotoneaster (spp), Buddleia (Buddleja davidii)
  • On the mudflats- Cord Grass (Spartina anglica)
Sustainability Appraisal Report Card- Biodiversity July 2016 https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/535161/SA_Report_cards_Biodiversity.pdf
Geographr: Karl and Ali CC BY-SA 2.0

Manmade impacts

  • The bay probably reached a stage of dynamic equilibrium in the 1830s and again (after sea defences were added) in the 1950s
  • As the training walls deteriorate the estuary will return to a more natural meandering regime, with implications for saltmarsh erosion and flood defence stability
  • Geological features around Walney Island are vulnerable to changes of sediment movement caused by sea defenses
  • "Holding the line" to defend coastal towns and villages may mean losing low-lying coastal habitats such as sand dunes, saltmarshes, mudflats
  • However preferred plan predicts net gain of intertidal saltmarsh, sandflats and mudflats around the bay
Northwest Shoreline Management Plan http://www.allerdale.gov.uk/downloads/nw_shoreline_management_plan_2.pdf
Geographr: Les Hull CC BY-SA 2.0

How can we mitigate against climate change?

  • Peat bogs and woodland contribute to carbon sequestration and storage, but if degraded will emit significant amounts back into the atmosphere
  • Salt marshes regulate many coastal processes such as flooding and erosion
  • Tree planting along rivers shades water, reducing temperature rises
  • "Re-alignment" or moving defenses back to higher land because of flood risk may increase opportunities for additional intertidal habitats
National Character Area Profile 20: Morecambe Bay Limestones http://publications.naturalengland.org.uk/file/4885946728185856
Geographr: Gerald Massey CC BY-SA 2.0

Back to the beginning

The climate of the bay is dynamic and has been fluctuating between periods of relative stability, and dramatic change, for millennia, and it's probably heading for another period of change now. Mitigation against some impacts is possible, but may cause additonal problems. The bay must be considered holistically so we can try to minimise the impacts across the board.

Geographr: Karl and Ali CC BY-SA 2.0

Additional References

  • Jellyfish: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-devon-33988083
  • Morecambe Bay Natural Area Profile http://www.sssi.naturalengland.org.uk/science/natural/profiles%5CnaProfile118.pdf
  • Lune Estuary- Channel Coastal Observatory http://www.channelcoast.org/northwest/latest/index.php?link=&dla=download&id=7&cat=1/Lune-Estuary_processes_report_Final.pdf